EU Commission proposes tougher penalties for cybercriminals

Loading

At the end of last week, the European Commission presented a new directive intended to punish computer attacks more severely and make the fight against them more effective.

Animal repellents Non-destructive
deterrence of
rodents,
wildlife
and snakes.

Lawmakers around the world are considering ways to combat cybercriminals, illegal downloading and the publication of illegal content. Their efforts are slowed, however, by the need to balance security with the protection of users’ privacy and fundamental rights.

Compared with existing legislation, the new directive increases, for example, the maximum penalty for more serious forms of computer attack that individual EU states must introduce into their criminal codes.

For an attack using a tool capable of compromising a large number of computers or causing major financial damage or data loss, such as a botnet, the maximum penalty must be at least five years. The maximum penalty must also be at least five years for an attack carried out under another real person’s identity or as part of a criminal group.

Assisting computer attackers will also be a criminal offence, and according to European Commissioner Cecilia Malmström, this will include, for example, creating and selling malicious software.

Unauthorized interception or monitoring of an information system will also be a criminal offence.

The new directive still requires majority approval in the EU Council of Ministers and the European Parliament. Member states will then have two years to incorporate the new rules into their legislation.

Cybercrime

A recent report by security company Sophos revealed that the greatest internet risk comes from sites such as Facebook and MySpace. Other major threats include email attacks, attacks on new devices such as BlackBerry and iPhone, and phishing — attempts to trick users into revealing passwords, for example to their bank accounts.

Some countries have already established dedicated units overseeing internet security. Dutch police, for example, have created an Internet Brigade to combat cybercrime. In Britain, the Internet Watch Foundation operates an online hotline where the public and software specialists can report potentially illegal internet content.

Advertisements

In addition, the pan-European agency ENISA monitors spam, or unsolicited email; botnets, networks of computers linked so they can all be controlled from one place; phishing; identity and data theft; chat services; peer-to-peer systems, or P2P file-sharing between users; harmful mobile-phone content; hackers involved in share trading; software vulnerabilities; and a lack of protection, such as security software, on some devices.

The Commission recognizes its lack of powers in this area. In April 2010, it therefore called on ministers to consider establishing a centralized agency to combat cybercrime and prevent online fraud and child pornography. In the past, the strongest opponents of this idea were Britain, Germany and France, which feared an EU agency would encroach on operations they were already conducting.

The Commission has also begun work on a new directive aimed at combating attacks on information systems and intends to present the EU Internal Security Strategy in October this year, with cybersecurity as a central component. According to Commission estimates, cybercrime costs the Union €750 billion a year, around one per cent of total GDP, exceeding even the drugs trade.

The European Commission therefore plans to establish a European rapid-response system for cyberattacks and strengthen ENISA’s role.

Internet piracy

According to the latest study on internet piracy by Paris-based consultancy Tera, the problem could lead to the loss of more than a million jobs and cost companies €240 billion over the next five years. Three quarters of the illegal consignments intercepted by European customs officers in 2009 were sent by post or air, indicating an increase in online sales of illegal items, according to the annual report on illicit trade published by the European Commission’s Taxation and Customs Union department.

The European Parliament is also trying to address this problem, but many of its members oppose criminalizing piracy. In their view, this would be too harsh and would also punish people who share files only occasionally, rather than on a mass scale or for commercial purposes.

France is the first country to have proposed legislation in this area. Many consider its law too severe, however. It works on a “three strikes” principle: users caught downloading illegal content three times can be disconnected from the internet. The law still requires approval by the French parliament.

At the beginning of May, Ireland became the first country to put a three-strikes policy into practice, after the Irish Recorded Music Association sued internet service provider Eircom over the volume of content illegally downloaded through its service.

The British government and internet service providers BT and TalkTalk, meanwhile, are in dispute at the Supreme Court over the Digital Economy Act, which requires companies to send warning letters and even disconnect customers who download illegal content.

Advertisements

One frequently discussed issue at European and global level is service providers’ role and responsibility in illegal downloading. The European Parliament is currently discussing proposals in the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement (ACTA) under which providers themselves would punish customers who downloaded illegal content.

In addition to the European Union, ten key players are involved in negotiating the agreement. The Commission represents EU interests. Swedish MEP and Swedish Pirate Party founder Christian Engström, who follows the negotiations, recently withdrew from talks with the European Commission after discovering that he was not allowed to share information about ACTA with fellow lawmakers.

Terrorism

In 2007, the EU created a security portal called “Check the Web”, allowing member states to report information about Islamic propaganda to Europol in The Hague. Authorities are also expected to ask internet service providers and private online companies to cooperate more closely in combating terrorism. A tougher stance on online propaganda and radicalization was already evident when the Commission adopted the Framework Decision on combating terrorism in November 2008. The document clearly states that “the internet is used to inspire and mobilize local terrorist networks and individuals in Europe, and also serves as a source of information about terrorists’ means and methods, acting as a virtual training camp”.

The Commission therefore believes the proposed new measures will make it easier to arrest both perpetrators and planners of attacks, as well as those who indirectly support terrorism in various ways, for example by distributing bomb-making instructions online.

The Union is due to introduce new measures against radicalization and recruitment, including online activity, in 2011.

Child pornography

The European Commission is also asking member states to prevent child pornography online and introduce tougher penalties for human trafficking. The European Parliament has already expressed doubts, however, about whether the new EU laws in this area will be sufficiently tough.

The legislation proposed in March this year is intended to help block child-pornography websites, prevent victims from being lured through online discussion forums, and ensure that offenders cannot resume their activities in another country. Here too, the EU faces opposition from member states concerned that excessive internet control will damage freedom of expression and allow governments to block other unwanted content under the pretext of a security risk.

Germany, which says it will block the proposal, argues that an outright ban on child pornography would make much more sense than filtering content.

Advertisements
AliExpress

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *