Lie about Jesus? eg. children. It helps them…
![]()
The Christmas holidays are approaching and with them accompanying myths, the most famous of which is the story of Jesus, who brings gifts to the children under the tree. During this period, many children hear talk about how they must be obedient and how Jesus knows exactly what every child wants.
Despite the many absurdities and contradictions in the original story, it is surprising that the child will really believe it. And so my research also shows that 83 percent of five-year-old children think that Santa Claus, or his similar Santa Claus, is real.
Why?
Evolutionary advantage?
The basis of this paradox is a very simple question regarding the nature of a small child, who is inherently a trusting being – he will believe everything you tell him.
Well-known author and ethologist Richard Dawkins presented in his 1995 essay the idea that children are trusting and believe in almost everything. He also indicated that this credulity is an evolutionary advantage for children.
He showed this quite convincingly on the example of a small child who lives near a swamp with alligators. A child who is skeptical and prone to critical evaluation of advice from his parents, so as not to go swimming in the swamp, has much less chance of survival than a child who listens to his parents without thinking.
This opinion about children is shared by many, including Thomas Reid, a philosopher from the 18th century, and developmental psychologists. They claim that children are very prone to believe what people will tell them.
Not very different from adults?
Nevertheless, my research shows that children are actually rational and thinking consumers of information. They use the same tools as adults to believe. What are these tools by which adults decide what to believe and what is the evidence that they are also used by children?
I will focus on three: one of them is the perception of the context in which the new information is embedded. The second is the custom of comparing new information with an existing knowledge base. And the third is the ability to evaluate other people’s experiences.
Let’s look at the context first.
Imagine that you are reading an article about a new type of fish – let’s call them, for example, ‘surnity’. Then imagine that you are reading an article in two different contexts: in the first scenario, your doctor is late and you are reading a copy of the National Geographic magazine, the official magazine of the American scientific society, in the waiting room.
In the second context, you will come across a report of the discovery on the cover of a tabloid magazine while you are waiting in line in front of the grocery store. I think the context in which you first get acquainted with the information will guide your judgment about this new fish.
Basically, we did the same with the children. We told them about animals they had never heard of, such as surnites. Some children learned about them in a fantastic context, in which we told them that they were collected by dragons and ghosts.
Other children learned about surnites in a scientific context, in which we told them that they were used by doctors and scientists.
Children at the age of four claimed that Surnity really existed if they learned about them in a scientific context and not fantastic.
How children use knowledge and expertise
One of the basic ways adults learn new things is listening to others. Imagine hearing about a new type of fish from a marine biologist compared to a neighbor who often tells you about alien aliens.
Whether you believe that a fish actually exists depends on how you evaluate the expertise and credibility of these two people.
In another research project, we showed young children new animals that were either possible (for example, a fish that lives in the ocean), the impossible (a fish that lives on the moon) or unlikely (a fish as big as a car). Then we let them decide for themselves whether the given animal exists or ask someone else about its existence. They also heard news from a breeder in a zoo (expert) and a cook (non-expert).
We found that children believe in possible animals and completely reject the impossible. These decisions were made by children based on a comparison of the information with their existing knowledge.
As for the unlikely animals that could exist, but are either very rare or strange, the children believed in them more if they were told by an animal breeder and not by a cook.
In other words, children use expertise as well as adults.
They are adults
If children are so smart, why do they believe in Santa Claus or Santa?
The reason is simple: parents and other people will do everything to support this myth. In a recent study, we found that 84 percent of parents take their children at least two Santa imitators at Christmas time.
There is also an ‘official’ mail for Santa Claus and Santa.
Why do adults feel obliged to go to such extremes?
Children are not thoughtlessly trusting and do not believe everything we tell them. So we adults have to overwhelm them with evidence – an open window through which the baby Jesus entered, gifts that suddenly appeared under the tree.
how children evaluate
Given this effort, it would be essentially unreasonable if the children did not believe. By believing in Jesus, children actually practice their scientific thinking.
First, they evaluate the sources of information. As my research suggests, they will believe an adult rather than another child.
Second, they use evidence (for example, gifts that suddenly appeared under the tree) to come to a conclusion about the existence of Jesus.
Thirdly, research shows that the more difficult to understand children, the more they become interested in the absurdities of this myth – for example, how a father or mother always mysteriously disappears before Jesus brings gifts.
What to say to your children?
Some parents wonder if they are hurting their children by supporting the myth of Jesus or Santa. Philosophers and bloggers have different arguments against these ‘liers’. Some even claim that they can lead to permanent distrust of parents and other authorities.
So, what should parents do?
There is no evidence that faith or mistrust in Santa Claus or Santa significantly influences trust in parents. In addition, not only do children have the tools to trace the truth, but by getting involved in the myth of Jesus, they actually practice this ability.
So, if you want to give your children gifts under the tree secretly this year as well and claim that they are from Jesus, you should do so. Your kids will be fine. And maybe they will learn something.
The author is a psychologist.
This article was originally published on The Conversation website. You can read the original English version here. For a better cultural understanding, Santa Claus was replaced by Jesus in some places.











