How to Use a Chargeback to Get Your Money Back After a Card Payment

Loading

Contents

A chargeback can protect you from dishonest merchants and when goods you paid for never arrive. However, there may be some things about chargebacks you did not know.

 Nedeštruktívne Technoogie ktoré nikde nekúpiš. 

Did you pay by card and the merchant failed to deliver the goods or service you ordered? Or did you receive something different? You can then use a powerful consumer tool called a chargeback, or payment reversal. Under certain conditions, you can recover your money. This is one of the main advantages of payment cards.

Examples are easy to find. When SkyEurope went bankrupt, some banks refunded customers for unusable tickets through chargebacks. The failed airline also showed how commercial banks’ approaches can differ. Some waited for the dispute process to finish, while others paid customers from their own funds.

What Is a Chargeback?

A chargeback is the process by which a cardholder disputes a transaction charged by a merchant through their card issuer, mainly because of:

  • failure to provide a service;
  • non-receipt of goods or services; or
  • delivery of different goods or services.

Duplicate charges also fall into this category. Essentially, it is a complaint about goods or services, but submitted to the bank rather than the seller. The bank then informs the merchant that the transaction has been questioned and requests all related documentation. Since chargebacks are costly for both banks and merchants, it is better to use them only when a normal complaint directly to the merchant has failed or is not reasonably possible.

Technically, the card issuer asks the merchant’s bank directly to process a chargeback, and the amount is then reflected in the card issuer’s nostro accounts. The merchant’s bank therefore loses the money immediately and seeks to recover it from the merchant. It is an automated process, but not as simple as it looks. Chargebacks are popular tools for fraud, so banks resist them and require supporting documents. It often resembles bank-to-bank ping-pong: one sends a chargeback request, the other rejects it, and the process repeats.

For an honest merchant, a chargeback can even be very dangerous, particularly with customers using American Express cards. The company has strict terms, and if merchant and customer cannot agree, the customer is always right. Owners of Prague’s cut-glass shops have countless sad stories of losses after shipping goods abroad and receiving a dispute directly through the card issuer.

Conversely, the expense of chargebacks is why some issuers prefer to resolve a complaint promptly and cover it themselves without the merchant ever knowing. Why? It is cheaper. However, it depends on the disputed amount. An issuer will respond differently to a claim over roughly 500 Slovak crowns wrongly charged at a petrol station, above the fuel actually purchased, than to tens of thousands or repeated complaints.

PayPal, GoPay, Agmo… Payment Intermediaries

An increasing number of merchants do not accept cards themselves but use payment gateways, aggregators or intermediaries such as PayU, GoPay, PayPal or Skrill. The transaction then shows the payment intermediary’s name rather than the merchant’s.

A reader asked the Měšec editorial team how chargebacks work with these intermediaries, fearing they might not be possible. The immediate answer is that there is no need to worry: payments through an intermediary follow the same rules as direct merchant payments.

“It is the same process. The card transaction details, in the authorisation or clearing message, identify the institution that submitted the payment for settlement. During a dispute, the card issuer, not the cardholder, communicates with the submitting institution, not the merchant. The transaction submitter is responsible for contractually securing the merchant’s cooperation in the event of a complaint,” explains Barbora Minksová from Cetelem, describing the intermediary process. “When 3D Secure is used, the process differs only if the customer claims not to have made the transaction,” adds Pavel Zúbek from GE Money Bank. Vladimír Komjati from Air Bank confirms the same approach: “If a customer pays through an intermediary, a possible chargeback follows a very similar process. We simply approach the payment intermediary directly instead of the merchant.” “The aggregator is merely another link in the payment chain. The acquirer (issuing bank) therefore does not request the merchant’s response to the cardholder’s dispute directly, but approaches the aggregator, which then contacts the merchant. This creates no complication for the customer or issuing bank except imprecise transaction wording on the account statement, which may confuse the customer. This creates no complication for the customer or issuing bank except imprecise transaction wording on the account statement, which may confuse the customer,” concludes Klára Pačesová from Slovenská sporiteľňa.

Advertisements

Nevertheless, exceptions exist. Tomáš Kelemen from Diners Club describes them:

“The payment service user, meaning the cardholder or payer, instructs the provider to pay the merchant, the recipient. A credit card payment to another provider is therefore treated as a cashless transfer between two payment service providers, an ‘account-to-account transfer’. There is therefore no reason to dispute the payment transaction with the card issuer, because the transfer most likely followed the user’s instruction. For example, a user wants to pay merchant Abc from PayPal but lacks sufficient funds in their PayPal account, so uses a credit card to top it up; PayPal then transfers the funds to merchant Abc. A payment to such a provider, meaning a transfer to an account with another provider, can also be made by means other than a credit or debit card, such as a bank transfer. For this reason, the credit cardholder should dispute the transaction directly with the payment service provider that made the payment to the recipient, the merchant.”

Expobank takes the same view, represented by Alena Nováková: “This is not the same process. A customer could, for example, dispute with the bank a card top-up to PayPal where the credited balance does not match the transaction amount. The bank would then pursue a chargeback with PayPal. If goods are not delivered, the complaint is handled directly with the merchant or intermediary; PayPal, for example, has a Resolution Centre. The intermediary then pursues the complaint with the merchant.”

The other issuers’ responses also show that even a chargeback directly involving a merchant is not always successful. These are official responses from the card issuers contacted.

Remember

  • You have 13 months to dispute a card transaction, but do not delay: the likelihood of success decreases each day.
  • Keep all transaction documents, including emails, orders, receipts, photographs, recorded calls and screenshots.
  • If you first top up funds with a payment intermediary or aggregator, such as an electronic wallet, and only then make the payment, dispute it with the intermediary. If the payment merely passes through the intermediary, you can request a chargeback from your card issuer.
  • Chargebacks are often abused by fraudsters for personal gain, so issuers examine their validity in considerable detail.

Air Bank

In practice, chargebacks have a very high success rate. However, the customer must submit the complaint promptly, preferably as soon as they cannot agree a refund directly with the merchant within the set period, and provide evidence of everything. Customers should also always read the merchant’s terms carefully, preferably before buying, and check for any specific delivery deadlines or conditions for the product or service.

Cetelem

Submitting a chargeback does not guarantee recovery of the disputed amount. In the event of a technical error, such as duplicate charging, success is very likely. For a signature-authorised transaction, where the cardholder is verified by comparing the signature on the card with the receipt, the merchant may argue that its staff are not trained handwriting experts and therefore could not detect or prevent misuse of the card.

The arbitration committee of the relevant card scheme has the final say on disputed transactions, assessing the dispute procedures and documentation submitted by the card issuer or submitting institution.

When buying flights, booking hotels or renting cars, read the contractual terms carefully before paying. Insufficient understanding of service arrangement fees or cancellation terms can cause a dispute to fail. The same caution applies to recurring payments that operate like a direct debit from a payment card.

Česká sporiteľňa

A chargeback, an interbank dispute procedure, adds value to payment cards and is an advantage over cash or cash-on-delivery payments. If the complaint is confirmed as valid, the customer does not lose their money. For example, we resolve cases where delivered goods differ from the website description, are damaged or counterfeit, never arrive, or the merchant misses the delivery deadline. The result is that the merchant either supplies the goods or service under the original purchase agreement or refunds the amount to the cardholder’s account.

ČSOB

If a customer contacts us about a chargeback, our bank handles the issue through the standard payment dispute procedure, for example an online payment disputed because goods were not delivered. If goods ordered online do not arrive, the customer contacts their bank and submits a normal complaint. The bank accepts it and queries the merchant through the merchant’s bank.

Advertisements

If the merchant cannot prove delivery, the complaint is accepted and the money is credited to the customer’s card or account. Disputes are usually resolved within 30 days. If card association deadlines make this impossible, the customer is informed about progress and the final resolution deadline. Paying online by card is therefore advantageous: if goods are not delivered, the bank handles everything, leaving the customer with no further worries.

The same applies to terminal payments. If you pay for a holiday in advance by card at a travel agency branch and the agency later goes bankrupt, you can also dispute the terminal payment with a good chance of success, depending on the cause. A specific past example is an airline’s collapse and subsequent refunds of card payments for its tickets.

Equa bank

A chargeback is not a dispute process with a 100% success rate. Although the bank initiates it on behalf of the cardholder, the other party can submit evidence showing that the charge was legitimate. Each case is assessed individually, with the procedure selected in accordance with card association rules.

Generally, a cardholder has the right to ask their bank to open a dispute over a transaction, but must also provide all cooperation the bank requests. In some cases, association rules expressly require the cardholder to communicate directly with the merchant, meaning an attempt to contact it and resolve the disputed transaction directly.

The bank’s experience is that the more truthful information and supporting material the cardholder supplies, the greater the bank’s chance of recovering the money. A cardholder should not refuse all cooperation while expecting the amount always to be credited back to their account.

Expobank

A chargeback can never be guaranteed 100% successful. However, today, with consumer interests and protection taking priority, most valid complaints end in the customer’s favour, even where the bank fails in the chargeback procedure and incurs a loss by reimbursing the customer.

Fio banka

Chargebacks give card users a way to recover money when a merchant fails to deliver ordered goods or services. They certainly cannot be described as 100% successful, because merchants have rights too. A chargeback essentially opens dispute proceedings over a challenged transaction, always governed by card association rules. Timing matters: the sooner the complaint is submitted, the better.

Naturally, the online shop’s or company’s terms must also be considered, as they may set exceptions concerning delivery times or methods. Fio banka always tries to assess each case individually and, where possible, help customers complete the dispute successfully.

GE Money Bank

The process has rules governed by the card associations. In disputed cases, the association decides, and its decision can never be certain.

The customer must explain all facts connected with the transaction and supply every document. Often customers lack documents, making recovery harder for the bank, or fail to disclose all relevant facts. An excessively old transaction is another obstacle. Customers have 13 months to complain, but the bank is in a much stronger position when a transaction is disputed immediately after posting. Checking transactions promptly is very important. Customers should also consider which websites receive their card numbers, including dating sites, film download services and other portals.

Because the terms are usually in English, few people read them. Customers register and are then surprised by recurring payments. As a bank, we recommend reading the terms and not submitting card numbers and CVC2 codes to unfamiliar websites.

Home Credit

In the overwhelming majority of cases, the chargeback is accepted. Rejection would require a truly fundamental error by the customer.

mBank

The card company’s rules, VISA in our case, must always be followed, and the documentation VISA requires must be supplied. It is essential to try resolving the issue with the merchant first and provide the correspondence or evidence of the attempt.

Precise details of the goods are also necessary. “Television” is not enough: it should be, for example, “Sony XMP32546 television”. Further information includes when delivery was due, whether the goods arrived damaged or differed from the description, and when, where and how they were returned, including tracking number and proof of posting.

If all required information is provided within the proper deadlines, the likelihood of success is high. The other party can, of course, reject the complaint and rebut the evidence with its own documents. Generally, the customer must tell the bank everything necessary, provide supporting evidence and keep it informed of changes, for example if the goods subsequently arrive.

Raiffeisenbank

A customer can, of course, ask their issuing bank to open a dispute or submit a chargeback, provided that:

  • They first fulfil the “merchant contact” requirement and attempt to resolve non-delivery directly with the merchant. This condition is set by the card associations.
  • If the merchant does not respond or help resolve the issue, RB can then open a dispute with the bank representing that merchant.
  • All available documentation for the disputed transaction must be supplied: the order with an exact description of goods or services, delivery date, when and how the customer tried to resolve the situation directly, and the merchant’s response, including where it did not respond or could not be contacted.

A dispute or chargeback is not always 100% successful. If the customer genuinely did not receive the goods or service, they naturally get their money back, but we investigate every case carefully. If the merchant supplies proof of delivery or other transaction documentation, it is sent to the customer for assessment.

Many customers simply cannot correctly match transactions where the merchant’s name is replaced by an aggregator or intermediary. It is therefore important to match the right amount to the right order, keep track of payments and know when goods or services are due.

UniCredit Bank

Where a cardholder disputes undelivered goods or an unprovided service, the merchant, meaning the party with whom the transaction took place and whose account received the payment, must prove delivery to the recipient’s address or provision of the requested service. This is governed by the Product Terms and Conditions forming part of the bank’s agreement with its business partner.

No party involved in a chargeback can always be assured of 100% success. Several factors affect the process.

First, success depends on whether the cardholder submitted the dispute to their bank on time. If it was not submitted within the deadline set in the Product Terms and Conditions, the bank representing the cardholder could not initiate a chargeback, even if the cardholder possessed all evidence that the transaction was charged improperly.

Evidence is very complicated in cases involving delivered or undelivered goods and provided or unprovided services. The same applies to disputes about the quality of services or goods ordered online. Generally, proving a transaction’s legitimacy is more difficult when the cardholder is not physically present.

Volksbank Löbau-Zittau

If the customer submits a complaint on time and substantiates it, the money is refunded. Within Volksbank Löbau-Zittau’s range, this applies only to credit cards. Its standard VPay and Maestro debit cards do not allow internet payments.

Zuno Bank

If a customer orders goods or a service and pays through a payment gateway, they should address the issue directly with the merchant. They need to keep all purchase documents: the order with a precise description of the goods or service, voucher, invoice and payment method, including payment through a gateway.

If the customer paid by card rather than bank transfer and the merchant promised a refund, or failed to respond to the customer’s written request, the customer can contact the card issuer. All documents and original correspondence must be attached, for example screenshots of emails showing the date and both parties’ email addresses.

Card transaction disputes follow precisely defined rules set by international card companies VISA and MasterCard. A chargeback is only part of the dispute process, which may or may not succeed.

If the bank has complete records, the likelihood of winning is high. Sometimes the customer no longer has a voucher or order because they did not download it and the website has been blocked. The bank can still initiate a dispute in such cases, but success is not assured.

Customers also often order goods from a prominent brand even though the website, merchant’s name or price makes it clear they are counterfeit. The merchant may have shipped them, but they never reach the customer because customs officers seize them, for example. In this case, the customer must accept the risk that a card dispute may also fail. People should address such situations promptly.

Advertisements
AliExpress

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *