Stealing Gets Harder — One Hundred Days of Contracts Online
![]()
Activists compare disclosure of contracts with the adoption of the Freedom of Information Act and putting the Commercial Register online.
BRATISLAVA. Officials attending a ball at a five-star hotel at state expense, overpriced diesel at transport companies, the fees paid to public television presenters, suspicious discounts by Slovak Post, expensive external advisers to the health minister, and media training for the transport minister by an expert from Israel.
These were among the issues covered by the media in recent weeks thanks to one of the new government’s most discussed measures.
Activists Are Satisfied
Government politicians often present mandatory online publication of contracts, which has applied to all state institutions and local governments since January, as their showcase achievement. Activists agree: public contracts allow them to scrutinize the handling of public money better than ever before.
ANTI-CORRUPTION MEASURES
• Mandatory publication of contracts online
• The Freedom of Information Act
• Making the Commercial Register available online
“It is this government’s strongest anti-corruption measure. It has a strong preventive effect on officials, both through publication itself and through its automatic nature,” says Transparency International director Gabriel Šípoš.
Peter Kunder of the Fair-play Alliance also regards it as a breakthrough in the transparency of state administration. “Its impact can be compared only with the adoption of the Freedom of Information Act and making the Commercial Register available online.”
Experts from various fields and local activists also praise the new tool.
“It has exposed some relationships in local government that raised doubts about contracts being unfairly steered toward connected people. Some illogical steps by mayors, councilors and officials can now be better explained,” says Prešov city councilor and activist Richard Drutarovský.
Information technology expert Štefan Szilva, on the other hand, encountered a problem precisely because a certain contract did not appear online.
“I discovered that a contract worth more than €58 million for new functionality on the Central Public Administration Portal, through which authorities are obliged to provide electronic services, has still not been published. This non-publication raises questions.”
It Will Help Expose Mismanagement
According to activists, mandatory publication of contracts could eventually have an impact similar to the adoption of the Freedom of Information Act in 2000.
That Act has already enabled the exposure of an enormous number of cases of opaque financial management, from national government to municipal level.
“The Freedom of Information Act is an excellent tool, but if you do not know exactly what you are looking for, it will not help. This new approach changes publication from passive to proactive. The public knew nothing about the noticeboard tender for a year and a half after it was concluded, until someone familiar with the circumstances brought it to light,” Šípoš says.
Publication Has Its Shortcomings
BRATISLAVA. Despite high expectations, activists remain cautious. The first hundred days of publishing contracts have also exposed serious flaws in the system.
“Many contracts are published only formally. Either an appendix defined as an integral part is missing, or key information is blacked out. From the perspective of public scrutiny, publishing contracts that do not even make clear whom the state bought from, what it bought and for how much is completely pointless. There are thousands of such contracts,” warns Peter Kunder of the Fair-play Alliance.
“The administrative burden has proved to be a problem, one the government also neglected in its communication with the institutions concerned. Our monitoring found that many towns, as well as state institutions, do not publish contracts in a way that makes them easy to navigate, search or analyze,” says Gabriel Šípoš of Transparency International.
The system also continues to suffer from technical shortcomings. For example, there is no website where all contracts can be searched and compared. While state authorities publish contracts in the Central Register of Contracts, local governments and their organizations post them on their own websites. Small municipalities, meanwhile, send them to the Commercial Bulletin.
In practice, the technical parameters of publication also remain unfinished. Many institutions publish contracts without any accompanying data or in a format that cannot be searched.
Source: sme.sk, 18 April 2011










