Convicted Lawyer Returns
![]()
BRATISLAVA. After four years, the Constitutional Court has reopened the corruption case of lawyer Pavol Polakovič. It found a violation of his right to judicial protection and ordered the Supreme Court to reconsider the matter.
His colleague Mária Mešencová testified against Polakovič and subsequently paid the price. It was the first time a lawyer had become a police agent. Her colleagues expelled Mešencová from the Slovak Bar Association for cooperating with the police.
The Special Court convicted Polakovič of corruption, and the Supreme Court upheld his two-year suspended sentence. It also rejected his extraordinary appeal, which it must now reconsider. “No hearing date has been set,” the Supreme Court’s press department wrote.
Unclear Bribery Charge
Among other things, the Constitutional Court judges criticised the Supreme Court for failing to make clear why Polakovič was tried for bribery. “The Supreme Court gave no answer as to why the complainant’s conduct fulfilled the elements of bribery rather than incitement to perjury.”
If the case had not involved corruption, Polakovič would have appeared before a district court rather than the Special Court.
According to the Constitutional Court, the lawyer’s right to a judge assigned in accordance with the law was also violated. The Supreme Court had rejected the suggestion that Judge Juraj Majchrák was biased and allowed him to decide the case. Majchrák had initially wanted to withdraw because he knew Polakovič’s mother, who worked at the Supreme Court.
What celebrities would give for such popularity, writes Lukáš Fila.
She Could Act as an Agent
The constitutional panel that ruled on Polakovič’s complaint consisted of Peter Brňák, Marianna Mochnáčová and Milan Ľalík.
Polakovič also complained that the court had accepted Mešencová’s testimony. He argued that a lawyer could not take on the role of an agent. The Constitutional Court rejected this part of his complaint.
Judge Ľalík attached a dissenting opinion. “The proper functioning of the legal profession, with agents absolutely excluded from its ranks, is a substantially higher value for a state governed by the rule of law than relying on its participation in detecting criminal activity.”
Polakovič had previously made several submissions to the Constitutional Court, without success.
An Angry Lipšic
The Constitutional Court’s decision to uphold Polakovič’s complaint is unacceptable and scandalous, says Interior Minister Daniel Lipšic of KDH.
“We need to ask citizens whether they want a class here that stands above the law and can get away with anything. They can engage in corruption and nothing happens to them, because if they cannot find someone at the Supreme Court, they will find someone at the Constitutional Court,” Lipšic said.
While in opposition, Lipšic represented Mešencová before the Supreme Court. Although that court ruled at the time that a lawyer could not be an agent, it restored her membership of the Bar Association. Mešencová remains a practising lawyer and says her clients have already forgotten the old case. “I work completely normally. I had hoped I would no longer have to return to this matter.”
Polakovič is no longer a lawyer, having been convicted of a criminal offence. According to the judgment, he offered Mešencová 100,000 crowns (more than €3,300) to persuade her client to change his testimony in favour of defendant Vladimír Strýčko in the light heating oil case, in which the state lost hundreds of millions of crowns.
Tuesday, 28 June 2011 | Zuzana Petková
History of the Case
The Lawyer
In 2004, lawyer Polakovič allegedly gave his colleague Mešencová a bribe so that her client would change his testimony;
Acting as a police agent, Mešencová provided evidence against him. The Bar Association expelled her for cooperating with the police. Polakovič received a two-year suspended sentence. The Constitutional Court cast doubt on the corruption case in which a lawyer was punished for acting as an agent.











