Cities and municipalities complain about the abuse of the Information Act. Many themselves violate it
![]()
Cities and municipalities complain about the abuse of the Information Act. Many themselves violate it
The complaints of municipalities to bully from citizens are exaggerated, the study showed.
Bratislava. For months, the Ministry of Justice has been preparing an amendment to the law on free access to information, through which some citizens allegedly bully state offices and local governments and distract them from work.
“The law cannot be a source for someone having their diploma theses done and cannot even be a source for information that someone can abuse in trade,” Prime Minister Robert Fico declared in June at the Assembly of the Association of Towns and Municipalities of Slovakia.
Political scientist Martin Dubéci, who works as an adviser to the deputy speaker of the parliament, Erika Jurinová (OĽaNO), undertook to verify what the reality is.
“It would be great if the legislation in this country was changed based on data and evidence and not for necrotic experiences,” he wrote on the blog.
Students are a scarecrow
In the analysis, he approached 599 municipalities of different sizes and asked them about the numbers and content of information requests that they have dealt with in the last three years.
He found that small villages, on average, do not receive more than one or two information requests per year. Larger cities receive an average of one information request per week.
“Even here, it’s still not about liquidation numbers for city offices, which often have dozens of employees, and nothing prevents them from publishing information proactively on the Internet,” says Dubéci.
People most often asked about the salaries and remuneration of officials, about public procurement, conclusions of negotiations of self-governing bodies, the use of public spaces or construction procedures.
According to the political scientist, the analysis did not even confirm the complaints of local governments. “We did not observe the same repetitive questions at the same time, which would indicate the collection of documents for the comparative work.”
The vice-president of the Association of Towns and Municipalities of Slovakia, Michal Sýkora, does not question the results of the analysis. “Problems with the info law may not be widespread, but that does not mean that individual municipalities do not have huge problems with it,” he claims.
Dubéci also admits this and points to the example of Trenčín, where officials had to repeatedly deal with requests to make the rules available for wearing head coverings of the city police.
“One of the possible solutions is the automatic publication of information that citizens are asking about,” he advises.
The Information Act does not apply everywhere
However, the study revealed another problem. As many as 38 percent of municipalities did not respond to requests according to the law. Some did not speak at all, others only with an irritated email.
“I am very pleased with your interest in our work. Since I see no reason why I should kill time with some statistics of an unknown person for me, I am not preparing answers for you,” they replied, for example, to the request of Veľké Držkovce in the Trenčín region.
“Regardless of whether or not there is a reason for a specific information request not to be granted, all obliged persons should react substantively and politely and either make the requested information available or issue a written decision within the specified period,” Jana responded Zlatohlávková from the Ministry of Justice.
The ministry has already invited Dubéci for consultations, the results of the study will be taken into account when preparing the amendment.
Reaction samples:
I don’t know for what purpose you need this information, but I consider it useless buzzing and if you think you’re going to be smashing some funds, you’re wrong. Mašková village, Banská Bystrica region
We are a village that does not have a worker, because it has one… And, thank God, we didn’t have any information request, at least I hope. Breznica village, Prešov region
I am an old structure and I recognize a more serious leaf form. I realize one thing that is once written on the net, can’t be taken back. Village of Fekišovce, Prešov region
You deprived us of two working days to ensure the proper operation of the municipal office. Village of Haniska, Košice region
Michal Piško sme.sk
The man from Prešov asked the school for information about what remuneration was paid to the school management And he was threatened and insulted by the director himself.











