Child Abuse with the State’s Tacit Blessing
![]()
On 23 March, Markíza’s TV news carried an incredible report: Vladimír Filip, director of the re-education home in Spišský Hrhov, had resigned. This happened after a resident, Simona, accused him of physical violence and wrote a complaint to the Ministry of Education. Simona was hospitalised with concussion. Filip filed a criminal complaint against her and five other girls (!) and then resigned. Yet few people have any idea what had been happening in the Hrhov manor house for years beforehand.

We first ended up in Spišský Hrhov by chance. I was supposed to write an article about underage victims of human trafficking, several of whom were in Hrhov, and I took my brother Vlado Holina along as the photographer. Even on the way there, I could not understand why victims needed to be re-educated, but what we found in the manor house exceeded even our worst expectations.
These facilities are supposed to be educational institutions, not judicial ones, and they come under the Ministry of Education, not the Ministry of Justice. Yet truants are locked up there alongside the aforementioned victims of organised prostitution, thieves alongside victims of domestic violence, orphans and children from two-parent families whose less intellectually gifted parents thought a state institution would deal with their children’s difficult adolescence for them. We spoke to a girl whose mother had sold her to pimps in Germany. When she refused to work as a prostitute, they beat her with chains in a forest. She eventually escaped, and her homeland shoved her into a reform school. Another girl had been abused by her father. During the investigation, her mother could not cope, sided with the father and had the child sent for re-education. Intelligent children are stuck there alongside children with intellectual disabilities until they are nineteen — with no opportunity to take their school-leaving examination. The re-education home is a dreadful parade of our society’s inability, in the 21st century, to deal with its defenceless members.
Director Filip put us up in the room where parents stay overnight on visiting weekends. That evening we discovered that the room key was a master key. We used it to open the nearest door and found something unbelievable behind it: a windowless room with a bed and a bucket, barely bigger than the bed itself. When we switched on the bare light bulb, a terrified girl jumped out of bed. That was how we discovered that the director punished children by locking them in cells he had told us were used to store potatoes.
After returning and taking a quick look at the relevant laws, we reached roughly the following conclusions: 1. The very existence of re-education homes is something unbelievably perverse, producing yet another generation without hope. 2. The material conditions in which the girls are confined are more reminiscent of developing countries. (On our very first visit, we went to the village to buy them toilet paper and soap.) 3. The statutory framework violates human rights and the International Convention on the Rights of the Child. 4. Even these poor laws are not followed there. The largely unqualified staff do whatever they like, emboldened by the fact that the facility is in the middle of nowhere.
The next time we visited Hrhov, we were already there as the civic association Druhá pomoc, with a car full of donated goods, and began looking around with a somewhat better-informed eye. Of course, bringing one or ten carloads of toiletries and cleaning supplies to a place like this, or sending a lorry full of computers (ironically, a gift from the Ministry of Education that had to be channelled through the voluntary sector), is almost entirely pointless. But the idea was to get inside the manor house and gather as many arguments as possible against the way it operated.
At first, Director Filip welcomed us with open arms — he liked to present the donations as a triumph of his own diplomacy — and we did not yet know that the law did not allow him to let us into the manor house at all. The trouble was that, apart from photographs of the old isolation cells, whose use the director denied anyway, we could not obtain any evidence of his mismanagement. For example, he explained the scene in the photograph on the left by saying that the girl had wanted to go there for a nap. Although the girls’ trust in us grew, none was willing to speak on camera about the re-education practices in the manor house. For one thing, they did not believe anything could change; for another, their fear of the director prevented them from speaking in anything but hints, even without a camera.
For a long time, all we had was the conviction that this sick system needed to change. Then two crucial things happened almost simultaneously. Director Filip finally realised that he was letting trouble through his door. After all, our attitude towards his institution was not that difficult to guess, and when he saw photographs of girls behind bars instead of happy groups outside the manor house, he could work out that we might do him more harm than good. He let us go through the usual Potemkin opening to the visit and then threw us out of the manor house. Just before leaving, we brazenly helped ourselves to the so-called Punishment Register and photographed a page proving that residents were being locked in isolation for far longer than the statutory maximum of 72 hours, and for reasons that beggar belief. I could not believe they even put it in writing, given that a prosecutor from Prešov regularly visited to carry out inspections — but that merely demonstrates how meaningful such inspections are.
Punishment Register: The first line tells us that a child is to spend 9 days in isolation because she “wrote on the wall with a pen”.
The second development was positive: a discharged resident, Eva T., was the first person willing to write a complaint together with me, and even then only about the misuse of the “old” isolation cells. Following our premise that we needed to tackle Filip through his breaches of the law rather than venture into vaguer issues for the time being, the point of this complaint was to demonstrate that isolation cells in Hrhov were not being used as the law required.
The law specifies what a “protective room” must look like, what it must contain, the circumstances in which a child may be placed in it and the maximum time: 72 hours. We submitted complaints and reports to the Ministry of Education and the Centre for Human Rights, while Lucia Nicholsonová, then working for TA3, undertook to produce a television report about it.
I cannot remember how the Centre for Human Rights fobbed us off, but I have the letter in which the Ministry of Education informs me that “the submission by Nataša Holinová, statutory representative of Druhá pomoc, and Eva T. concerning violations of residents’ human rights… has been referred directly to the Regional School Office in Prešov and the State School Inspectorate in Prešov for handling.”
Of course, I might have guessed that Filip was hand in glove with his regional supervisory bodies and that “nothing out of the ordinary would happen on their watch”.
The TA3 report was an outright disaster: not because of its fleeting impact, nor because Filip used it to promise me exactly what he had sweetly announced when throwing us out of the manor house: a criminal complaint, because I was supposedly providing legal assistance to the residents. (At the time, I told him just as smoothly that I would very much like to do so but, unfortunately, I was not a lawyer.)
The problem was that Lucia Nicholsonová committed a serious journalistic blunder by revealing to the director the identity of a source who, trusting us, had been willing to speak in the report on condition of anonymity. Lucia deeply regretted it and explained it to us as a stupid mistake and a human failing on her part. But the girl concerned was too frightened to return from leave and was therefore officially classed as having absconded. Meanwhile, the doors of the re-education home were closed to us for ever, so I can only guess how far the girls’ trust in us must have fallen.
We could think of no steps beyond those described. I saw no point in filing a criminal complaint against the director, because, given the minimal evidence against him, I still assume that the prosecutor from Prešov would merely have popped in for a drink. Yet I note that the Ministry of Education has known since 2006 that the Spišský Hrhov re-education home was not operating properly and that human rights and children’s rights were being violated there. The ministry appears to have done nothing whatsoever with this information, because it took a previously unimaginable complaint directly from a resident in March 2011, followed by Director Filip’s remarkable behaviour. I also listened with displeasure to the reaction of the current State Secretary at the Ministry of Labour, Social Affairs and Family: “My assessment was that the girl had evidently probably lost trust in the re-education facility…” Lucia Nicholsonová gives the impression that she has never been to Hrhov and never filmed a report about human rights violations within its walls. Someone went there and still failed to understand. Someone fortunate enough not to have been prevented from taking her school-leaving examination, and for whom ending her education was simply a matter of choice.
The Regional School Office also seems rather surprised when it now states: “…methods of repression predominated in the re-education work…”
Will the state authorities at least do something about it now?
Update, 2 June, 13:00:
At a meeting initiated by Minister Mihál, we learned that Lucia Nicholsonová had devoted exceptional attention to the problem of re-education facilities and that, thanks to her, Director Filip had been removed from his post. We were told that another institution and another person had been holding this up; we must wait for their statements.
Nataša Holinová, Monday 30 May 2011, 09:35










