But can a lie detector be fooled?
![]()
He personally participated in the creation of a system for testing asylum seekers in the USA, which helps the defense in federal courts. Tests in three languages: English, Spanish and Vietnamese. “I teach all my students the basic principle that the role of a polygraphic examiner never changes. I mean, we are, in all circumstances, unbiased truth-seeking people,” says Patrick Coffey. The fate of people depends on his ability to ask accurate questions and evaluate complex mathematical answer algorithms. It can prevent the conviction of the innocent, but also prove that a person considered innocent lies. But above all, his mission serves primarily to protect the truth-tellers, not to convict liars.
Non-destructive
deterrence of
rodents,
wildlife
and snakes.
But can a lie detector be fooled? Can the perpetrator, after a long time since the act, suggest a consistent theory, which he believes to the extent that the result of the test does not prove that he is lying? “Let’s assume that would be the case, but I’ll ask him if he’s lying to me the moment we’re talking to each other, now and here. And that’s how his whole theory collapses,” Coffey replies. But what if a person does not remember the deed after 30 years? “Fine. Would you remember if you killed someone at the age of twelve?” The examiner will answer with a counter-question. The PDD test works on a simple principle. There are functions of our body that we cannot control by will. And they are measured by sensitive devices during the test. Coffey explains, “We have a heart that beats.
{Googleads Right}
Apart from the change in heart rate, we can’t do anything about it, while the autonomic nervous system completely controls this area. Another area we focus on is skin moisture changes on the tips of the fingers. So we look at the increases or decreases in the skin resistance of the tested subject. We look at the recording of the course of the curves, as a person breathes in the abdomen and chest. Even if a person could control it, we will find that he is trying to do something with curves, which automatically indicates that he is trying to deceive the test.” Coffey mentions examples from his practice: the test convicted the killer by the color of the belt with which the victim was suffocated, or the room where the deed took place. No one else knows them, only investigators and the perpetrator. And if the examiner in the test appropriately asked the seven colors of the given belt (or room type or caliber of the weapon) in the test, while one correct, innocent person passes the test – unlike the offender.
Unexplored terrain
The lie detector is a practically unknown concept in Slovakia. There is an opinion among the public that it is not very reliable, and therefore only a tool of evidence that is difficult to use in criminal proceedings. It is used for security and other checks by seventeen police officers, SIS and NBU. These are mostly graduates of psychology and law, who have been trained by experts from the USA and Israel.
Former Minister of Justice and member of the National People’s Republic of Slovakia Daniel Lipšic states for .tježden: “Our criminal code does not regulate the use of a polygraph. Anything that was obtained in a legal way is referred to as evidence and evidence is only used in an exemplary manner as an interrogation, expert Appraisals or confrontation. The principle of free evaluation of evidence applies. I can imagine that a polygraph could be an effective means of investigation. Sometimes there are different investigation versions, and if the police were able to qualify one of them, it would be of great importance.
However, in the court proceedings itself, it is an unexplored territory.” Lipšic believes that, as with the Crown Witness, the polygraph should not be considered as the only incriminating evidence. He decided that the results of the examination of the accused on the polygraph cannot be used as evidence.
The missing legislation in this area is also pointed out by the lawyer of the two accused in the Cervanová case, Allan Böhm. Neither of them ever confessed to the act. At the same time, he reminds that one of the other accused has been vehemently demanding a lie detector test since 1981. unsuccessfully.
Böhm says: “If I were to request the use of a polygraph on behalf of my clients, the Slovak court will not respond because I do not know the standard I should refer to. In addition, my clients are demanding a DNA sample and comparisons with samples They may have found themselves with the victim and are still in the laboratories of Prague, what about the court? He just smiles and ignores it. According to him, the lie detector could significantly help not only in verifying the truth of the claims of the accused, but also of witnesses, because after 1990 everyone retracted their previous statements and claimed that they were forced to do so – psychologically and some even by physical pressure.
Accuracy to 95 percent
What is the practice abroad like? The Supreme Court of the United States still has to decide on the admissibility of the polygraph as evidence. In one decision, he said that polygraphic tests could interfere with the 5th Amendment of the Constitution (Schmerber vs. California, 1966). In some U.S. court systems, the absolute prohibition of the admissibility of polygraphic results is a proof.
A third of the states of the Union do not accept the polygraph as evidence, based on the case of Frye vs. of the 1923 US, when there was a fear that the jury would be so biased that it would not take into account any other evidence besides this. Since then, however, the technology of the polygraph has been radically improved, in the 1990s, increasingly powerful computers with higher quality software have replaced analog evaluation with the help of “pencil and paper”.
The American Polygraphic Association (APA), which unites more than 3,200 examiners (professionally qualified examiners) and is therefore the largest organization of its kind in the world, has published research studies related to the reliability of polygraph testing. There are 80 research projects available, the results of which have been published since 1980. During this research, the results of 6380 polygraphic tests were checked. The researchers conducted 12 studies on the validity of polygraphic examinations directly in practice, and the results of 2174 cases of practical testing were also used, while the average accuracy of all results was 98 percent. Other studies report an accuracy of 92 percent, but experts have settled at 95 percent.
“In studies conducted in the USA, in science, statistical significance, i.e. 95 percent or more, is considered to be the criterion of reliability of any method. The polygraph met this criterion in more than 200 studies,” says Coffey.
How does the truth detector work – lies – you can also buy on verbwww.market.sk
The term polygraph itself means “more graphs, more curves”. According to the APA, this name refers to the way selected physiological activities are simultaneously recorded. The polygraphic device collects physiological data from at least three systems in the human body. Rubber hoses are attached to the chest and abdomen of the test subject, which record respiratory activity. Two small metal plates are attached to the fingers, which monitor the activity of the sweat glands. Furthermore, a cuff is attached to the body of the subject, which senses blood pressure and cardiovascular activity.
A typical polygraphic test consists of a so-called pre-test, a phase of obtaining charters (curves, diagrams) and a phase of analyzing the data obtained during the test. In the pre-test phase, the examiner fills out the required documents and talks to the tested subject about the test. Discuss the questions to be asked and familiarize the examinee with the test procedure.
In the data collection phase, he creates several polygraphic charts, diagrams. He then analyzes them and forms an opinion with regard to the truthfulness of the person who has undergone the test. It is important that the polygraph does not contain a physiology analysis that is related to the voice. Tools that record the voice and detect stress in the voice cannot be considered a polygraph, and their reliability is not scientifically proven.
{Googleads Right}
Proponents and opponents of this method often argue about how the obtained data are evaluated. Critics who do not understand the technique of polygraphic testing sometimes classify undecided test results as errors. However, this is the result when it is not possible to judge whether the subject is telling the truth or lying. In real life, this means that the examiner is not able to provide a definitive diagnosis. In such cases, another test is usually carried out. Coffey refers to repeatability as an extremely important criterion of scientific accuracy of the Coffey polygraph. He emphasizes that in case of any doubts about the possible result of his test of convicts in the Cervanová case, the diagrams can be evaluated by his Slovak students.
We will not fool the body
A frequent argument of opponents of this method is that although the polygraphic technique is extremely accurate, it is not without errors. These can be caused by insufficient preparation of the subject for the test or poor interpretation of physiological data. Errors are mostly referred to as false positives or false negatives. That is why the principle of repeatability and verifiability is extremely important. Another guarantee of impartiality is the application of high-performance computers and extensive databases of tests that are compared. Examiners use standard multi-step evaluation using computer software, with the oldest of them – Grandfather Sotware – being developed in 1992 by US government funding at the best workplace of its kind, applied in laboratories physics at John Hopkins University. Its version 5.5 is currently in use.
The examiner does not ask any subtle or complicated questions. On the contrary, the questions are known in advance, they are simple and the examinee commits to answer yes or no. The test itself is preceded by a smaller test, in which the ability of the given person to process information and undergo a lie detector is determined. The most serious risk – that the tested one will deceive the lie detector with a consistent theory, which he will believe, even if it is contrary to reality – is evaluated by the head of psychiatry from Trenčín, Jozef Hašto. “There are known cases of displacement, within defense mechanisms, when a person has it “assembled” in consciousness differently than it actually happened. However, it is generally true that he always has a memory trace stored in him, as it really happened, and with a correct stimulus word or a statement in a sentence, it is directed to the construction in his consciousness, but at the same time a bodily vegetative reaction is also manifested, which corresponds to the displaced truth,” he states for .week, adding that the lie detector does not serve as indisputable evidence.
In case of Cervanová, the use of a lie detector could bring a fundamental shift. .The week will therefore focus intensively on this topic.
Andrejban










